This 1986 University of Pittsburgh Law Review article examines who should own intellectual property rights in computer-generated output when no agreement explicitly allocates those rights. Pamela Samuelson evaluates ownership by computers, users, programmers, joint authors, or no one. She argues that allocating rights to the user best fits copyright doctrine, practical enforcement considerations, and incentives to bring works to market. She also contends that computer-generated output generally is not a derivative work of the generator program, while recognizing program owners’ rights when output incorporates substantial recognizable protected expression.
Free preview text
The first 5 pages, shown as text so search engines and readers can find this document.
UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH LAW REVIEW
d. What Happens If One Takes the Computer
Out of the Problem? ...... .. ................ 1218
e. Congress Did Not Intend to Give Copyright
Owners an Exclusive Right to Use a
Copyrighted Work .......................... 1219
V. Should Both the User and the Programmer Be
Considered Joint Authors of Computer Output? ......... 1221
VI. Why Give Anyone Ownership Rights in Computer-
Generated Works? .......... ............................ 1224
I. INTRODUCTION
As "artificial intelligence" 1 (AI) programs become increasingly
sophisticated in their role as the "assistants" of humans in the crea-
1. "Artificial Intelligence" is a term used to describe a specialty field within computer science
that is aimed at producing computers that exhibit intelligent conduct. See, eg., Shurkin, Expert
Systems: The PracticalFace of Artificial Intelligence, 8 TECH.REv. 72 (1983).
A system is judged to have the property of intelligence, based on observations of the sys-
tem's behavior, if it can adapt itself to novel situations, has the capacity to reason, to
understand the relationship between facts, to discover meanings, and to recognize the
truth. Also, one expects an intelligent system to learn, i.e., to improve its level of perform-
ance on the basis of past experiences.
ENCYCLOPEDIA OF SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING 110-11 (A. Ralston 3d ed. 1983) (entry on "Artifi-
cial Intelligence").
Although many people are profoundly skeptical about the ability of humans to design and build
truly intelligent machines-machines capable of learning, of designing, of thinking, of solving com-
plex problems-some very prominent scientists have undertaken the effort to investigate the possibil-
ity. See, e.g., Minsky, Why People Think Computers Can't, 8 TECH. REV. 65 (1983); H. SIMON, THE
SCIENCES OF THE ARTIFICIAL (2d ed. 1981); B. WEBBER & N. NILSSON, READINGS IN ARTIFICIAL
INTELLIGENCE (1981) (31 papers on various aspects and research concerning artificial intelligence).
The investigation has less to do with advanced mechanical design and more to do with some deep
theoretical assumptions about what rationality and thinking are all about:
According to a central tradition in Western philosophy, thinking (intellection) essentially is
rational manipulation of mental symbols (viz., ideas). Clocks and switchboards [for exam-
ple] ... don't do anything like rational symbol manipulation. Computers, on the other
hand, can manipulate arbitrary "tokens" in any specifiable manner whatever; so apparently
we need only arrange for those tokens to be symbols, and the manipulations to be specified
as rational to get a machine that thinks. In other words, Al is new and different because
computers actually do something very like what minds are supposed to do. Indeed, if that
traditional theory is correct, then our imagined computer ought to have "a mind of its
own": a (genuine) artificialmind.
J. HAUGELAND, ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE: THE VERY IDEA 4 (1985) (emphasis in original). For
a discussion of the optimistic predictions about the future of artificial intelligence developments, see
generally E. FEIGENBAUM & P. MCCORDUCK, THE FIFTH GENERATION: ARTIFICIAL INTELLI-
GENCE AND JAPAN'S COMPUTER CHALLENGE TO THE WORLD (1983). For a more journalistic
introduction to the work of a group of artificial intelligence researchers, see generally F. ROSE, INTO
THE HEART OF THE MIND: AN AMERICAN QUEST FOR ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (1984). Con-
cerning the potential and actual commercial implications of artificial intelligence research, see gener-
1186 [Vol. 47:1185
HeinOnline -- 47 U. Pitt. L. Rev. 1186 1985-1986
Page 3
RIGHTS IN COMPUTER-GENERATED WORKS
tion of a wide range of products-from music to architectural plans to
computer chip designs to industrial products to chemical formulae2-
the question of who will own what rights in the "output" of such
programs 3 may well become a hotly contested issue.4 Because
software is copyrightable, 5 and much software is now being copy-
righted,6 copyright law may be the doctrinal forum for the debate. 7
ally THE Al BUSINESS: COMMERCIAL USES OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (P. Winston & K.
Prendergast ed. 1984).
2. See, e.g., U.S. CONGRESS, OFFICE OF TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT, INTELLECTUAL PROP-
ERTY RIGHTS IN AN AGE OF ELECTRONICS AND INFORMATION 69-73 (1986) [hereinafter cited as
OTA REPORT] (discussing intellectual property problems presented by what OTA calls interactive
computing, by which they mean "any creative process in which a preliminary or final version of a
work that is the result of interactions between a person and a programmed machine," id. at 69;
giving numerous examples of programs that perform such functions, id. at 70-71, including a
flowchart for a music generator program, id. at 71); Special Issue on Computer Music, 17 ACM
COMPUTING SURVEYS 147-289 (1985); Blick, Computer-Assisted Chemical Synthesis Packages: Is
this a New Problemfor Patentability?,I J. INFORMATION SCI. 227 (1979); Feuer, VLSI Design Auto-
mation: An Introduction, 71 PROCEEDINGS OF THE IEEE 5 (1983); E. FEIGENBAUM & P. MC-
CORDUCK, supra note 1, at 61-75 (discussion of some existing "expert system" programs); Posner,
Architecture: Computers Do It Faster,'WallSt. J., Feb. 25, 1986, at 28, col. 1.
3. This Article will only consider the question of how ownership of intellectual property rights
in computer output should be allocated in the absence of an explicit allocation of ownership rights in
a sales or licensing agreement between the owner (or authorized distributor) of a generator program
and the user. An agreement which simply gives to the owner of the copyrighted generator program
the right to control the making of derivative works will not be considered an explicit allocation of
ownership rights in computer-generated works. See infra text accompanying notes 86-144 for a
discussion of the ambiguity of the derivative work right in this respect.
4. When one thinks of how widespread are uses of computer programs to generate other
works-both written works and industrial products-one can see that the stakes of the allocation of
ownership rights in computer-generated works are very high indeed. When the stakes are high and
the statute ambiguous, the stage would seem to be set for a hot contest.
5. Computer programs in machine-readable form were explicitly added to the realm of copy-
right subject matter by Pub. L. No. 96-517, 94 Stat. 3007 (1980) (codified at 17 U.S.C. § 101 (1982)).
Although there have been numerous challenges to the copyrightability of computer programs, see,
e.g., Data Cash Sys., Inc. v. JS&A Group, Inc., 480 F. Supp. 1063 (N.D. Il1. 1979), aff'd on other
grounds, 628 F.2d 1038 (7th Cir. 1980), it is now generally accepted that computer programs are
proper subject matter for copyright. See, e.g., Apple Computer, Inc. v. Formula Int'l, Inc., 725 F.2d
521 (9th Cir. 1984); Apple Computer, Inc. v. Franklin Computer Corp., 714 F.2d 1240 (3d Cir.
1983), cert. dismissed per stipulation,464 U.S. 1033 (1984). But see Samuelson, CONTU Revisited:
The Case Against Copyright Protection for Computer Programsin Machine-Readable Form, 1984
DUKE L.J. 663; OTA REPORT, supra note 2, at 7, 132 (arguing that computer programs because of
their functional character do not readily fit in the copyright system and may lead to transformation
of the traditional rules of the system).
6. See OTA REPORT, supra note 2, at 115.
7. The same kind of issue may surface in the patent system as well. See generally Blick, supra
note 2; Milde, Can a ComputerBean "A uthor"oran '"nventor"?,51 J. PAT. OFF. SoC'Y 378 (1969).
One of the significant differences between copyright and patent law that may affect how patent law
deals with the ownership issue is that patent law does not give the patentee the exclusive right to
prepare derivative works whereas copyright law gives such a right to copyright owners. Compare 35
U.S.C. § 271 (1982) with 17 U.S.C. § 106 (1982). Section IV.B., infra, will discuss the implications
11871986]
HeinOnline -- 47 U. Pitt. L. Rev. 1187 1985-1986
Page 4
UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH LAW REVIEW
It is a new sort of problem for copyright law. Until software was
admitted to its realm, copyright law had excluded utilitarian works-
that is, works that had functions beyond the conveying of information
or the displaying of some sort of appearance-from its domain.8 Of
the wide diversity of copyrightable works, only software is capable of
automatically generating "products," including many of a sort that
copyright itself will not reach (e.g., an industrial product).9 Congress
of the derivative work right in the copyright system as it affects the potential right of a programmer
to claim control over the computer output. Although the patent doctrine of equivalents provides
patentees with a basis for claiming rights in some derivative inventions, the range of derivatives that
a patentee may control under patent law may be narrower than the copyright law allows because
with patents, to be "equivalent," a derivative invention must do the same basic function in the same
basic way. See 4 D. CHISUM, PATENrs § 18.04 (1986).
8. Traditionally, copyright protection has extended to works whose only "utility" was the con-
veying of information or the displaying of some sort of appearance or sound. This principle is codi-
fied in the copyright statute at 17 U.S.C. § 101 (1982) (definition of "useful article"), id. § 113
(providing that useful articles embodying designs from copyrighted drawings do not infringe them)
and id. § 102(b) (processes not copyrightable). Works having other kinds of utilities besides convey-
ing information or displaying appearances-for example, chairs, television sets, and airplane
wings-have been excluded from protection by copyright. See H.R. REP. No. 1476, 94th Cong., 2d
Sess. 55 (1976) [hereinafter cited as HOUSE REPORT). See also infra notes 124-35 and accompanying
text. When Congress decided in 1980 to extend copyright protection to computer programs, see
supra note 5, this tradition was broken because computer programs, at least in machine-readable
form, do more than "convey" information or "display" appearances: they perform useful tasks. The
task that a program may perform may be the monitoring of the operation of a catalytic converter or
the injection of fuel into a car's carburetor, as easily as it may be the generation of an image on a
screen or a new piece of music. See OTA REPORT, supra note 2, at 78-85. ("Computer programs, as
hybrid functional works, describe and implement processes. They cause physical changes to occur in
a machine and can interact with other programs or with an environment. A recipe encoded in a
program language cannot only tell a programmer how to bake a cake, it can 'tell' the computer too.
With the appropriate robotic apparatus, the recipe can cause the cake to be baked." Id at 80.) See
generally Boraiko, The Chip, 162 NAT'L GEOGRAPHIC 421 (1982). While the "output" of a com-
puter program may be of many sorts, in the vast majority of cases the output is a different work, that
is, something different in kind-not just in form-from the program itself. See infra note 144 and
accompanying text.
While copyright has never had to cope with this kind of subject matter before, it is worth noting
that at least one other form of intellectual property law has had some experience with dealing with
ownership rights as to works produced through use of a protected work. Patent law has rules about
who owns rights in the "output" generated through use of a patented machine. Just because a
patentee has rights in the machine does not mean the patentee has rights in the output. A separate
product patent is needed to give the patentee rights in the output. Because patent law has more
experience with this type of problem, it may make sense to consider how this body of analogous law,
and not just copyright, would deal with the issue when deciding how ownership rights to works
generated through the use of a computer should be allocated.
9. The closest analogous subject matter to software in the copyright system seems to be the
category of sound recordings. Sound recordings may consist either of grooves cut into plastic or
magnetized segments of plastic tape that when used in conjunction with a machine (i.e., "played")
produce sounds corresponding to the sounds one might have heard at the live performance when the
recording was made. Neither the grooves nor the magnetized tape is precisely the same "work" as
[Vol. 47:1185
HeinOnline -- 47 U. Pitt. L. Rev. 1188 1985-1986
Page 5
1986] RIGHTS IN COMPUTER-GENERATED WORKS 1189
appears not to have understood that it was admitting a utilitarian sub-
ject matter to copyright when it passed the amendment explicitly rec-
ognizing the copyrightability of software.10 The computer-generated
works problem may require courts to confront this utilitarian quality
of software.II
Within the framework of the copyright law, intellectual property
ownership rights depend initially on "authorship." 12 That is, within
the music that was recorded, and yet they are enough the same work that copyright law will protect
the pattern of grooves or magnetization on tape in order to protect the value of the musical perform-
ance that corresponds to the pattern. The grooves are simply an alternate (if somewhat fuller and
richer) way of "recording" music than writing notes on paper.
By contrast, a work generated by use of a computer and its programs may be different in kind,
different in substance, and different in form from the original generator program. That is, there may
not be the kind of one-to-one correspondence between program and output as there is between a
sound recording and the sounds that may be heard when the recording is played. In fact, there may
be no discernible correspondence at all. The text of the output may not match any part of the text of
the program. Often it will be impossible to detect whether a particular computer-generated work
was generated by a computer at all (and not written by a human), let alone generated from a particu-
lar generator program. Computer-generation of output is thus significantly different from recorda-
tion of music. See infra notes 124-35 and accompanying text for a discussion of the useful nature of
computer-generated output and note 144 and accompanying text for a discussion of the purpose of
computer programs.
An analysis of the computer-generated works problem must focus on the ownership issue not
only when the type of work generated by a computer is of a sort that has traditionally been assumed
to be copyrightable (music, cartoons, statistical compilations), but also as to noncopyrightable sub-
ject matter. Software generator programs can generate patentable subject matter, chip design subject
matter, and unprotectable subject matter. See supra note 2 and infra notes 36-45 & 124-35 and
accompanying text.
10. See Samuelson, supra note 5, at 727-49.
1I.Courts have tended to downplay or ignore the utilitarian character of software in cases
which have raised the issue in the past. Compare the lower and appellate court decisions in Apple
Computer, Inc. v. Franklin Computer Corp., 545 F. Supp. 812, 823-24 (E.D. Pa. 1982), rev'd, 714
F.2d 1240, 1250-53 (3d Cir. 1983), cert. dismissed per stipulation,464 U.S. 1033 (1984). As the OTA
Report indicates, the functional character of software is creating severe doctrinal problems in appli-
cation of doctrine to software copyright cases. See OTA REPORT, supra note 2, at 79-85. The
courts, however, do not seem to be acknowledging their departure from traditional rules. Id at 81.
12. Section 201(a) of the Copyright Act provides that statutory copyright "vests initially in the
author or authors of the work." 17 U.S.C. § 201(a) (1982). Professor Nimmer states that "author-
ship is a sine qua non for any claim of copyright, be it statutory or (in the limited area remaining to
it) common law. That is, the person claiming copyright must either himself be the author, or he
must have succeeded to the rights of the author." 1 M. NIMMER, NIMMER ON COPYRIrHT
§ 5.01[A] at 5-3 (1985) (footnotes omitted). Neither "author" nor "authorship" is defined in the
statute, but some examples of authorship are described therein. See 17 U.S.C. § 102(a) (1982) (em-
phasis added) which provides in part:
Copyright protection subsists . . . in original works of authorship fixed in any tangible
medium of expression, now known or later developed, from which they can be perceived,
reproduced, or otherwise communicated, either directly or with the aid of a machine or
device. Works of authorship include the following categories: (1)literary works; (2) musi-
cal works, including any accompanying words; (3) dramatic works, including any accom-
HeinOnline -- 47 U. Pitt. L. Rev. 1189 1985-1986
Allocating Ownership Rights in Computer-Generated Works: summary, contents and background
This guide helps you understand the scope of Allocating Ownership Rights in Computer-Generated Works before or alongside reading the original document. It is based on the catalogue record, credited creator, source, classification and topics shown on this page. It does not replace the original work and does not invent claims about passages that Doxxly cannot verify.
Summary and overview
Allocating Ownership Rights in Computer-Generated Works is a 44-page documentcredited to Orson E. Sandford. This 1986 University of Pittsburgh Law Review article examines who should own intellectual property rights in computer-generated output when no agreement explicitly allocates those rights. Pamela Samuelson evaluates ownership by computers, users, programmers, joint authors, or no one. She argues that allocating rights to the user best fits copyright doctrine, practical enforcement considerations, and incentives to bring works to market. She also contends that computer-generated output generally is not a derivative work of the generator program, while recognizing program owners’ rights when output incorporates substantial recognizable protected expression. It appears in the Law & Legal Studies collection, which groups it with other material that readers may use for comparison and further study.
The item can be approached in several ways. A reader looking for a quick orientation can begin with the free five-page preview, inspect the page structure and use the metadata to judge relevance. Someone undertaking deeper research can work through the complete file, search its indexed text, record useful page references and compare its treatment of Copyright law, Computer-generated works, Intellectual property, Authorship, Derivative works, Joint authorship, Artificial intelligence, Legal scholarship with the related resources linked below.
Rather than reducing the work to a single claim, this page treats it as a source that should be read in context. The title, creator, publication source, licence and format all help explain what kind of evidence it may offer. Readers should distinguish the original author's statements from Doxxly's catalogue description, and should cite the original edition when using the material in academic, professional or published work.
Key topics and reader takeaways
The catalogue connects this document with Copyright law, Computer-generated works, Intellectual property, Authorship, Derivative works, Joint authorship, Artificial intelligence, Legal scholarship. These terms offer practical entry points rather than a substitute for close reading. Start by identifying the definitions, examples, arguments, tables or visual explanations attached to each topic. Then note where the creator draws connections, makes distinctions or moves from background material to a conclusion, recommendation, calculation or narrative development.
A useful reading method is to separate description from interpretation. First record what the item actually presents: names, headings, figures, formulas, quotations or stated propositions. Next consider why those details matter within the whole work. Finally compare them with another source from the same subject area. This process helps turn a long digital file into evidence that can be evaluated rather than merely skimmed.
Table of contents and reading guide
The following is an editorial content guide based on the verified catalogue topics. It is not represented as the original author's formal table of contents. Use it to organise notes while moving through the 44 pages in the player.
Part 1
Copyright law
Use this section of the reading guide to identify how Copyright law appears in Allocating Ownership Rights in Computer-Generated Works, note important terms, and connect the subject to the wider purpose of the work.
Part 2
Computer-generated works
Use this section of the reading guide to identify how Computer-generated works appears in Allocating Ownership Rights in Computer-Generated Works, note important terms, and connect the subject to the wider purpose of the work.
Part 3
Intellectual property
Use this section of the reading guide to identify how Intellectual property appears in Allocating Ownership Rights in Computer-Generated Works, note important terms, and connect the subject to the wider purpose of the work.
Part 4
Authorship
Use this section of the reading guide to identify how Authorship appears in Allocating Ownership Rights in Computer-Generated Works, note important terms, and connect the subject to the wider purpose of the work.
Part 5
Derivative works
Use this section of the reading guide to identify how Derivative works appears in Allocating Ownership Rights in Computer-Generated Works, note important terms, and connect the subject to the wider purpose of the work.
Part 6
Joint authorship
Use this section of the reading guide to identify how Joint authorship appears in Allocating Ownership Rights in Computer-Generated Works, note important terms, and connect the subject to the wider purpose of the work.
Part 7
Artificial intelligence
Use this section of the reading guide to identify how Artificial intelligence appears in Allocating Ownership Rights in Computer-Generated Works, note important terms, and connect the subject to the wider purpose of the work.
Part 8
Legal scholarship
Use this section of the reading guide to identify how Legal scholarship appears in Allocating Ownership Rights in Computer-Generated Works, note important terms, and connect the subject to the wider purpose of the work.
When a heading in the original differs from this guide, follow the original heading in your citation. Page numbers can also vary between editions. Doxxly's direct page field is useful for navigation, but formal references should include the title, creator, source and edition details available in the file itself.
About Orson E. Sandford
Doxxly credits Orson E. Sandford as the author or creator of Allocating Ownership Rights in Computer-Generated Works. This page does not add an unverified biography, job title or institutional affiliation. The attribution is preserved so readers can distinguish the creator from the hosting library and follow the original record when an external author link is available.
Author context matters because a work reflects a particular purpose, audience and point of view. Before relying on the material, consider what the creator set out to explain, when the source was produced and whether later research or revised guidance should also be consulted. For literature and philosophy, compare translations and editions; for technical material, check whether a newer version has superseded the one shown here.
About the source organisation
The recorded source for this item is law.berkeley.edu. Doxxly provides access and discovery tools but does not claim to be the original publisher unless explicitly stated. Source links, creator attribution and the recorded Publicly available file collected for editorial review licence are displayed to help readers assess provenance and permitted use.
Provenance is especially important for reports, standards, presentations and working spreadsheets. Check the original source for amendments, supporting files and current policy. A trustworthy research workflow keeps the source URL with any notes or downloaded copy, verifies important figures against the original, and avoids treating an archived document as automatically current.
Begin with the title and opening pages, then use the guide above to decide whether to read sequentially or move to a particular topic. The Doxxly player provides previous and next navigation, a direct page field, zoom steps, fit-to-width and fit-to-page modes, rotation and fullscreen. These controls are useful when a page contains small type, a wide table, an image, a scanned layout or a dense sequence of notes.
The first five pages are open to every visitor. A plan unlocks the complete item and full-document search. Search is best used for distinctive names, technical terms or short phrases; broad words can produce too many possible contexts. When you find a useful passage, read the surrounding pages so that a sentence, chart or formula is not separated from its explanation.
If downloading is enabled, members can obtain the original PDF file. Keep the original format when formulas, slide sequencing, pagination or layout carries meaning. Respect the Publicly available file collected for editorial review terms displayed on this page, and use the rights-report link if you believe the attribution or availability needs review.
Research questions to consider
As you read Allocating Ownership Rights in Computer-Generated Works, ask which audience the creator addresses, what problem or idea organises the work, what evidence is presented, and which assumptions remain unstated. Note whether important terms are defined consistently and whether examples represent a broader pattern or a narrow case. For quantitative material, record units, time periods, formulas and data sources. For interpretive material, separate the creator's language from your own summary.
A second set of questions concerns relevance today. Which parts remain durable, which depend on their historical or institutional setting, and what would need confirmation from a newer source? Following the tags and the Law & Legal Studies collection can reveal useful comparisons. Agreement between sources can strengthen confidence, while disagreement can point to changing definitions, methods, evidence or priorities.
Finally, decide what you need from the item: background knowledge, a quotation, a worked example, a model, a visual explanation or a starting bibliography. That purpose should guide the depth of reading and the notes you keep. Doxxly helps locate and navigate the source; careful interpretation remains the reader's responsibility.