The first 5 pages, shown as text so search engines and readers can find this document.
Page 1
When Choice is Demotivating: Can One Desire Too Much
of a Good Thing?
Sheena S. Iyengar
Columbia University
Mark R. Lepper
Stanford University
Current psychological theory and research affirm the positive affective and motivational consequences of
having personal choice. These findings have led to the popular notion that the more choice, the
better--that the human ability to manage, and the human desire for, choice is unlimited. Findings from 3
experimental studies starkly challenge this implicit assumption that having more choices is necessarily
more intrinsically motivating than having fewer. These experiments, which were conducted in both field
and laboratory settings, show that people are more likely to purchase gourmet jams or chocolates or to
undertake optional class essay assignments when offered a limited array of 6 choices rather than a more
extensive array of 24 or 30 choices. Moreover, participants actually reported greater subsequent
satisfaction with their selections and wrote better essays when their original set of options had been
limited. Implications for future research are discussed.
Ne quid nimis. (In all things moderation.)
--Publius Terentius Afer (Terence), c. 171 B.C.
It is a common supposition in modern society that the more
choices, the better--that the human ability to manage, and the
human desire for, choice is infinite. From classic economic theo-
ries of free enterprise, to mundane marketing practices that provide
customers with entire aisles devoted to potato chips or soft drinks,
to important life decisions in which people contemplate alternative
career options or multiple investment opportunities, this belief
pervades our institutions, norms, and customs. Ice cream parlors
compete to offer the most flavors; major fast-food chains urge us
to "Have it o u r way."
Sheena S. Iyengar, Graduate School of Business, Columbia University;
Mark R. Lepper, Department of Psychology, Stanford University.
We gratefully acknowledge the cooperation and assistance of Draeger's
Grocery Store located in Menlo Park, California, for generously offering
their store as a field site for conducting Study 1. Similarly, Study 2 could
not have occurred without the cooperation and support of Claude Steele at
Stanford University who generously allowed his introductory social psy-
chology course to be used as a forum for conducting this field experiment.
Further, we would like to thank the numerous graduate students in the
Department of Psychology at Stanford University and undergraduate re-
search assistants who generously dedicated their time and effort to help
conduct these studies.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Sheena
S. Iyengar, Columbia University, Graduate School of Business, Uris Hall-
Room 714, 3022 Broadway, New York, New York 10027-6902, or to Mark
R. Lepper, Department of Psychology, Jordan Hall-Building 420, Stanford
University, Stanford, California 94305-2130. Electronic mail may be sent
to ss957@columbia.edu or lepper@psych.stanford.edu.
On the face of it, this supposition seems well supported by
decades of psychological theory and research that has repeatedly
demonstrated, across many domains, a link between the provision
of choice and increases in intrinsic motivation, perceived control,
task performance, and life satisfaction (Deci, 1975, 1981; Deci &
Ryan, 1985; Glass & Singer, 1972a, 1972b; Langer & Rodin,
1976; Rotter, 1966; Schulz & Hanusa, 1978; Taylor, 1989; Taylor
& Brown, 1988). In a typical laboratory study, the intrinsic moti-
vation of participants is compared across two conditions: one in
which participants are given a choice among half a dozen possible
activities, and a second in which participants are told by an
experimenter which specific activity to undertake (Zuckerman,
Porac, Lathin, Smith & Deci, 1978). The recurring empirical
finding from these studies is that the provision of choice increases
intrinsic motivation and enhances performance on a variety of
tasks.
Moreover, the positive consequences of choice are often appar-
ent even in contexts where the choice itself is trivial or incidental
(Cordova & Lepper, 1996; Dember, Galinsky, & Warm, 1992;
S w a n n & Pittman, 1977). Indeed, many important theories in
social psychology, including attribution theory (e.g., Kelley, 1967,
1973), dissonance theory (e.g., Collins & Hoyt, 1972; Cooper &
Fazio, 1984; Linder, Cooper, & Jones, 1967), and reactance theory
(e.g., Brehm, 1966), all presume that even purely illusory percep-
tions of choice will have powerful effects (Langer, 1975; Lefcourt,
1973; Lewin, 1952).
Although prior research has made a compelling case for the
psychological benefits of the provision of choice, there remain
some potential limitations to this literature. Consider one seem-
ingly trivial, yet potentially important, methodological character-
istic of prior studies: that the number of options presented in
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2000, Vol. 79, No. 6, 995-1006
Copyright 2000 by the American Psychological Association, Inc. 0022-3514/00/$5.00 DOI: 10.1037//0022-3514.79.6.995
995
Page 2
996 IYENGAR AND LEPPER
previous experiments was characteristically small, typically be-
tween two and six alternatives. It would appear, then, that what
prior research has actually shown is that choice among relatively
limited alternatives is more beneficial than no choice at all. Pre-
sumably, of course, constraints on the number of options offered in
past choice studies were imposed primarily for the sake of conve-
nience; however, real-world situations often provide more than a
limited selection, sometimes even an overwhelming number of
options. What happens when the range of alternatives becomes
larger and the differences among options become relatively small?
Certainly, there are cases when even a vast array of choices may
still have beneficial effects. Imagine a group of people who arrive
at a new restaurant, for example, all hoping to order their personal
favorite dishes. Obviously, the more items offered on the menu,
the more satisfied these customers will be, on average. More
generally, in preference-matching contexts, in which people enter
hoping to find some particular product or service they already
know themselves to prefer, larger numbers of options should
increase the likelihood that they will be successful in their search.
On the other hand, a growing body of research also suggests that
people can have difficulty managing complex choices. To begin
with, research has shown that as the attractiveness of alternatives
rises, individuals experience conflict and as a result tend to defer
decision, search for new alternatives, choose the default option, or
simply opt not to choose (Dhar, 1997; Shafir, Simonson, & Tver-
sky, 1993; Shafir & Tversky, 1992). Furthermore, consumer re-
search suggests that as both the number of options and the infor-
mation about options increases, people tend to consider fewer
choices and to process a smaller fraction of the overall information
available regarding their choices (Hauser & Wernerfelt, 1990).
In fact, studies show that the selection, evaluation, and integra-
tion of information are all clearly affected by the available number
of options; this suggests that, as the complexity of making choices
rises, people tend to simplify their decision-making processes by
relying on simple heuristics (Payne, 1982; Payne, Bettman, &
Johnson, 1988, 1993; Timmermans, 1993; Wright, 1975). For
instance, a comparison of the decision strategies of people pre-
sented with three, six, or nine alternatives revealed that 21% used
an elimination strategy in the case of three options, 31% used an
elimination strategy in the case of six options, and 77% used an
elimination strategy when there were nine options (Timmermans,
1993). The increase in the percentage of participants who used an
elimination strategy as the number of alternatives grew was also
accompanied by a decrease in the percentage of information used.
This sharp decrease in the number of attributes considered as
problem complexity increases suggests that information overload
may produce a change to a noncompensatory but more efficient
decision rule.
The three studies presented in this article, therefore, examine for
the first time the possibility that there may be differential motiva-
tional consequences of encountering contexts that offer a limited
(i.e., psychologically manageable), versus an extensive (i.e., psy-
chologically excessive), number of choices. Specifically, the
choice overload hypothesis underlying these studies is that, al-
though the provision of extensive choices may sometimes still be
seen as initially desirable, it may also prove unexpectedly demo-
tivating in the end.
In these studies, limited-choice conditions were operationalized
as contexts that offered roughly the same number of options
(approximately six) as used in past research (e.g., Zuckerman et
al., 1978). In comparison, extensive-choice conditions were opera-
tionalized as contexts in which participants would have some
reasonably large, but not ecologically unusual, number of options.
In addition, to provide a clear test of the choice overload
hypothesis, several additional methodological considerations
seemed important. On the one hand, to minimize the likelihood of
simple preference matching, care was taken to select contexts in
which most participants would not already have strong specific
preferences. On the other hand, to minimize the potential impor-
tance of effortful information search, care was also taken to select
tasks for which "right" and "wrong" choices would be subjective,
so that the effort involved in making a choice would be largely a
function of personal preferences. Finally, across experiments, we
sought to examine this hypothesis in both field and laboratory
settings. Using these criteria, then, the present studies tested the
hypothesis that having a limited and more manageable set of
choices may be more intrinsically motivating than having an
overly extensive set of choices.
Study 1
In this first field experiment, consumers shopping at an upscale
grocery store encountered a tasting booth that displayed either a
limited (6) or an extensive (24) selection of different flavors of
jam. The two dependent measures of customers' motivation were
their initial attraction to the tasting booth and their subsequent
purchasing behavior.
Method
Participants and Experimental Site
Study 1 involved a field experiment that examined the motivational
consequences of limited versus extensive choice in an upscale grocery
store (Draeger's Supermarket) located in Menlo Park, California. This
grocery store is of particular interest because its salient distinguishing
feature is the extraordinary selection it offers, especially when compared
with large grocery chains. For instance, Draeger's offers roughly 250
different varieties of mustard, 75 different varieties of olive oil, and over
300 varieties of jam. In addition, because of the regular presence of tasting
booths at this store, shoppers are frequently offered sample tastes of the
enormous array of available products. As a result, this store provided a
particularly conducive environment in which a naturalistic experiment that
used tasting booths could be conducted.
On two consecutive Saturdays, neither of which fell on a long holiday
weekend, a tasting booth was set up inside the grocery store. Over the
course of these two 5-hr experimental periods, the behavior of approxi-
mately 754 shoppers was observed. Among the 386 customers present in
the store during the hours when the extensive-choice booth was displayed,
only 242 actually encountered the display. Among the 368 customers
present in the store during the hours when the limited-choice booth was
displayed, only 260 actually encountered the display. By observation, the
customers who stopped at the booth were typically middle-aged Cauca-
sians; approximately 62% of these customers were women and 38% were
men.
Product Selection
Exotic jams. Before the study, the number of brands and selections
within a number of product categories were carefully catalogued. On the
basis of the following criteria, the product selected as the experimental
Page 3
WHEN CHOICE IS DEMOTIVATING 9 9 7
stimulus was Wilkin & Sons (Purveyors to Her Majesty the Queen) jams.
To control for potential differences that might arise from different types of
packaging or advertising, it was necessary to find one brand for which there
was a sufficiently large variety to constitute an extensive-choice condition.
(In total, Wilkin & Sons has 28 varieties of jams.) In addition, careful
attention was given to selecting a product with which most consumers
would be familiar, yet not so familiar that preferences would already be
ftrmiy established. Hence, to ensure that potential customers would not just
reach for the more traditional flavors such as strawberry and raspberry,
these common flavors were removed from the set of 28, leaving a choice
set of 24 more exotic flavors. Finally, because the dependent measure
involved purchasing behavior, a relatively inexpensive product needed to
be chosen. The price of Wilkin & Sons jams ranged from 4 to 6 dollars.
Jam preferences survey. To ensure that the limited-choice set consisted
of neither the most preferred nor the least preferred jam flavors, a prelim-
inary survey of 30 Stanford undergraduates examined individual prefer-
ences for the 24 flavors of jam. These students were provided a list of
the 24 exotic jam flavors and were asked, "Please read the following list of
jams. Put a star next to the two best-sounding jams, in your opinion. Put a
check mark next to two good but not excellent-sounding jams, and an X
next to the two worst sounding jams." On the basis of this preliminary
survey, kiwi and peach jams were selected to represent the two most
preferred jams, black cherry and three-fruits marmalade were selected to
represent the moderately tasty jams, and lemon curd and red currant were
selected to represent the least preferred jams.
Procedure
Two research assistants, dressed as store employees, invited passing
customers to "come try our Wilkin and Sons jams." Shoppers encountered
one of two displays. On the table were either 6 (limited-choice condition)
or 24 (extensive-choice condition) different jams. On each of two Satur-
days, the displays were rotated hourly; the hours of the displays were
counterbalanced across days to minimize any day or time-of-day effects.
Initial testing. Consumers were allowed to taste as many jams as they
wished. All consumers who approached the table received a coupon for a
$1-discount off the purchase of any Wilkin & Sons jam. Afterwards, any
shoppers who wished to purchase the jam needed to go to the relevant jam
shelf, select the jam of their choice, and then purchase the item at the
store's main cash registers. As a result, regardless of the tasting-booth
display encountered by each customer, all potential buyers of Wilkin &
Sons products necessarily encountered the entire display of flavors.
An inconspicuous observer recorded the number of customers who
approached the table, as well as the number of passers-by who did not stop.
A second observer, also unobtrusive, made educated guesses about the
ethnicity, age, and gender of each customer who did stop at the tasting
booth.
In addition, a random sample of solicitations was tape-recorded and later
presented to two independent raters, unaware of both the conditions and
hypotheses of the study, who rated each solicitation on a 1-5 Likert scale
of "friendliness" ranging from not at all friendly to very friendly. Overall,
the average friendliness score was high (M = 4.5), and the correlation
between the raters was high, r = .90, p < .0001. Subsequent analyses on
these scores showed that the solicitations did not vary according to con-
dition, F(1, 99) = .86, ns.
Subsequent purchasing. On the bottom left-hand comer of each dis-
count coupon was a code indicating the condition assignment and gender
of each consumer. Other numbers and letters surrounded these codes to
lead customers to believe that the code represented a coupon scan number.
Coupons could be redeemed over a period of 1 week.
subsequent purchase o f the displayed product. As noted, more
w o m e n than m e n stopped at the booth; however, there were no
gender differences by condition, either for initial attraction or for
subsequent purchasing behavior.
Initial Attractiveness o f Selections
To what extent does having extensive choice initially s e e m
desirable? O f the 242 customers w h o passed the extensive-
selection display o f jams, 60% (145) actually stopped at the booth.
In contrast, o f the 260 customers w h o passed the limited-selection
display o f jams, only 40% (104) stopped. Thus, consumers w h o
encountered the extensive-choice condition were more attracted to
the booth than consumers exposed to the limited-choice condition,
suggesting that the variety provided in the extensive-choice con-
dition was initially more attractive, 9(2(1, N = 502) = 19.89, p <
.001.1
One might imagine that consumers w h o encountered 24 differ-
ent j a m s would sample more flavors than would those w h o en-
countered 6 different varieties. In fact, however, there were no
significant differences, F(1, 245) = 0.83, ns; consumers in the
extensive-choice condition sampled an average o f 1.50 j a m s
(range = 1-2), whereas consumers in the limited-choice condition
sampled an average o f 1.38 j a m s (range = 1-2).
Subsequent Purchasing Behavior
Is the initial attractiveness o f extensive choice also reflected in
subsequent purchasing behavior? Our findings suggest not: Nearly
30% (31) o f the consumers in the limited-choice condition subse-
quently purchased a j a r o f Wilkin & Sons jam; in contrast, only 3%
(4) o f the consumers in the extensive-choice condition did so, X2(1,
N = 249) = 32.34, p < .0001. Thus, consumers initially e x p o s e d
to limited choices proved considerably more likely to purchase the
product than consumers w h o had initially encountered a much
larger set o f options.
Discussion
These findings are striking. Certainly, they appear to challenge
a fundamental assumption underlying classic psychological theo-
ries o f h u m a n motivation and economic theories o f rational-
c h o i c e - - t h a t having more, rather than fewer, choices is necessarily
more desirable and intrinsically motivating. The findings from this
study show that an extensive array o f options can at first seem
highly appealing to consumers, yet can reduce their subsequent
motivation to purchase the product. Even though consumers pre-
sumably shop at this particular store in part because o f the large
number o f selections available, having "too m u c h " choice seems
nonetheless to have h a m p e r e d their later motivation to buy.
There are, however, several potential limitations to this initial
field experiment. To begin with, it is possible that consumers in the
limited-choice condition believed that there was something special
about the specific six j a m s displayed, especially after they b e c a m e
Results
The central aim o f Study 1 was to examine w h e t h e r the n u m b e r
o f options displayed affected c o n s u m e r s ' initial attraction to or
In keeping with current guidelines, because the cell sizes in the present
studies were substantial (Siegel, 1956) and because there were more than 5
times as many subjects as there were ceils (Delucchi, 1983), it was not
deemed necessary to perform a correction for continuity.
Page 4
998 IYENGAR AND LEPPER
aware o f the multitude o f other options available on the shelf. Such
a belief could have made the limited-choice consumers more prone
to purchase jam. Consequently, it is worth considering whether the
pattern o f results would be altered if the limited-choice condition
were operationalized such that participants were not aware o f the
multitude o f other options potentially available.
In addition, the contrasting displays o f j a m may have invited
motivationally differing c o n s u m e r groups. Although the display
o f 24 j a m s may have aroused the curiosity o f otherwise uninter-
ested passers-by, the display o f 6 jams may have appealed to store
customers w h o were more serious about the purchasing o f jam. To
rule out this possibility, it was necessary to examine the motiva-
tional consequences o f limited versus extensive choices with a
sample o f participants w h o were not given the opportunity to
self-select their condition assignment.
Finally, since consumers in both conditions sampled no m o r e
than two j a m flavors, it is possible that the consumers in the
extensive-choice condition felt that they did not have sufficient
time to determine their preferences. Although consumers in both
conditions were allowed the freedom to peruse and to sample as
many o f the displayed flavors as they wished, social pressure or
time constraints may have prevented them from taking full advan-
tage o f this opportunity. Thus, one might question whether the
obtained differences in motivation would be eliminated if partic-
ipants in both conditions were given the opportunity to peruse their
options in an unconstrained, nonpublic context.
Study 2 endeavored to address these concerns and to generalize
the findings from Study 1 to an educational setting, in which
measures o f actual performance, as well as choice, could be
observed. Thus, in Study 2, participants in the limited-choice
condition were not aware o f any options b e y o n d those in the
limited-choice set. Similarly, careful attention was given to choos-
ing a task that enabled participants to spend as much time as they
wished in perusing their choices. Moreover, unlike Study 1,
Study 2 e m p l o y e d a yoked design; the limited-choice set was
rotated such that for every item encountered by an extensive-
choice participant, there was a limited-choice participant w h o had
encountered the same item.
S t u d y 2
In Study 2, students in an introductory social psychology class
were given the opportunity to write a two-page essay as an extra-
credit assignment. Students were given either 6 or 30 potential
essay topics on which they could choose to write. Intrinsic moti-
vation was assessed by comparing the percentage o f students w h o
completed the assignment across the two conditions and the qual-
ity o f the essays written in each condition.
Method
Participants
One hundred ninety-seven students in an introductory social psychology
class at Stanford University served as the participants in this study. The
class included 116 women and 81 men. In addition to attending biweekly
lectures, all students were required to attend smaller weekly discussion
sections led by five graduate student teaching assistants. The students were
divided into 10 discussion sections; each of the five teaching assistants
led 2 sections. Sections included anywhere from 8 to 26 students. Four
students ultimately dropped the class and were therefore excluded from the
analysis.
Procedures
As part of the course, all students were required to watch the movie,
"Twelve Angry Men." Related to this requirement, an extra-credit assign-
ment was offered, and it was the administration of this extra-credit oppor-
tunity that provided the context for a naturalistic experiment.
Before Thanksgiving week, extra-credit assignments were distributed to
the students. All assignments included the following instructions:
Instead of having section next week, all students will be required to
watch a movie being shown in room 40 on Monday, November 25,
between 7-9 PM. After watching the movie, you can obtain two extra
credit points on your next midterm examination by writing a response
paper to the movie. The following is a list of possible questions you
can write about. Papers should be approximately one to two pages
typed, double spaced, and are due Tuesday, December 3, in class. If
you choose to do this assignment, you must circle the paper topic and
attach this page to your response paper.
After reading these instructions, students found themselves confronted
by either 6 different essay topics (limited-choice condition) or 30 different
essay topics (extensive-choice condition). All essay questions dealt with
topics related to the material covered in the course. Careful attention was
given to selecting essay topics that were comparable in difficulty, and
analyses of performance revealed no differences as a function of the
specific topic chosen.
In all, there were six different versions of the extra-credit assignment. In
addition to the 30-topic assignment, five versions of the 6-topic assignment
were created, such that all of the items from the list of 30 were counter-
balanced across the five limited-choice assignments.
Students were first informed of the movie requirement during the weekly
section meeting before Thanksgiving week. To minimize the possibility
that students would notice the different versions, assignments were handed
out in the section meetings rather than in class lectures. At this time, the
teaching assistants distributed these assignments, with an identical verbal
description, reinforcing the information about the opportunity for students
to gain two extra points on their next midterm. On no occasion were
students led to believe that their essays would be graded. On the contrary,
they were explicitly told that their performance on the assignment was
irrelevant to the receipt of the two points.
Because each of the five teaching assistants administered two separate
sections, one of these two sections was assigned to the limited-choice
condition and the other was assigned to the extensive-choice condition. In
this way, five sections of students received six essay topics and five
sections of students received thirty. Because the number of students per
section varied, it was not possible to assign equal numbers of students to
the two conditions. As a result, 70 students were assigned to the limited-
choice condition, whereas 123 students were assigned to the extensive-
choice condition. No differences were found across the five teaching
assistants in terms of assignment completion; students assigned to one
teaching assistant were just as likely to do the extra-credit assignment as
students assigned to another teaching assistant.
Dependent Measures
Two measures assessed students' subsequent motivation in the two
conditions. The first was the percentage of participants who chose to write
an essay. The second was the quality of the essays produced.
As previously indicated, the students were told that their performance on
these extra-credit assignments would have no impact on their class grades.
Nevertheless, it was of interest to determine whether the number of
alternatives available might also affect performance quality. Accordingly,
Page 5
WHEN CHOICE IS DEMOTIVATING 999
two graduate students, unaware of both the participants' choice conditions
and the hypotheses of this experiment, graded each of the response papers
for both content and form using two 10-point scales, which ranged from
"extremely poor" to "excellent. ''2
When grading for content, two factors were taken into consideration.
The first was the accurate depiction and appropriate use of social-
psychological concepts. The second was the use of clear examples from the
film that related and mapped onto the different social-psychological pro-
cesses being discussed. The inter-rater correlation for content scores was
r = .70, p < .0001. The form score similarly assessed students' facility on
two dimensions. First, each paper was judged on whether it had clear
structure (e.g., "Did the introductory paragraph define a hypothesis?").
Second, the papers were evaluated on technical proficiency--spelling,
grammar, and the like. The inter-rater correlation for form scores was r =
.89, p < .0001. Because there was considerable agreement across the two
graders on both content and form, their ratings were averaged, yielding one
content and one form score per student.
Results
Preliminary Analyses
The central point of interest in Study 2 lay, once again, in the
comparison of participants' responses across the two experimental
conditions of limited versus extensive choice. Because preliminary
analyses showed no differences as a function of gender and no
interactions between gender and condition on either measure, the
data were collapsed across this factor.
Assignment Completion
Did the number of choices provided on the instruction sheet
actually influence the percentage of students who completed the
assignment? Overall, 65% (126) of the students chose to do the
assignment. There was, however, a significant effect of condition,
X2(1, N = 193) -- 3.93, p < .05. Of the 70 students assigned to the
limited-choice condition, 74% turned in the assignment. In con-
trast, of the 123 students assigned to the extensive-choice condi-
tion, only 60% chose to complete the assignment.
Quality of Essays
Were these differences in students' willingness to write an essay
also reflected in differences in the quality of these essays? For
content, there was a main effect for condition, F(1, 124) = 4.18,
p < .05. On average, students assigned to the limited-choice
condition performed slightly, although significantly, better
(M = 8.13, SD = 0.95) than those assigned to the extensive-choice
condition (M = 7.79, SD = 0.91). A similar main effect was found
for form, F(I, 124) = 4.64, p < .03. On average, students in the
limited-choice condition scored higher (M = 8.04, SD = 1.33)
than students in the extensive-choice condition (M = 7.59,
SD = 1.02).
Because measures of content and form proved significantly
correlated (r = .52, p < .0001), content and form grades were also
averaged to give one overall grade. The condition effect was also
significant for this overall measure, F(1, 124) = 5.65, p < .02,
with students in the limited-choice condition receiving higher
grades (M = 8.09, SD = 1.05) than those in the extensive-choice
condition (M = 7.69, SD = 0.82).
One might ask whether the observed differences in motivation
or performance could somehow have been driven by differences in
students' prior performance in the class. There were, however, no
differences in class midterm performance by condition among the
students who completed the extra-credit assignments, nor were
there differences in midterm performance between those who
subsequently did or did not choose to do the assignment.
Discussion
The findings from Study 2 both confirm and expand on the
findings from Study 1. The results from both studies suggest that
the provision of extensive choices does not necessarily lead to
enhanced motivation when compared with contexts that offer a
limited array of choices. Quite the opposite seems to be the case.
In both studies, people actually seemed to prefer to exercise their
opportunity to choose in contexts where their choices were limited,
and, in Study 2, they even performed better in such limited-choice
contexts.
Particularly counterintuitive, from the perspective of traditional
models, is the finding that the same choice selected from a limited-
choice set can lead to better performance than if the same option
had been selected from an extensive-choice set. Interestingly, in
contrast to prior studies, the measure of performance in the present
experiment was designed to reflect intrinsic motivation. Because
none of the participants thought that their essays would be evalu-
ated, the quality of the paper they wrote should have been primar-
ily a function of their personal interest and motivation.
Thus, the results of Studies 1 and 2 support the hypothesis that
extensive-choice contexts may be initially more appealing but
are subsequently more likely to hamper people's intrinsic motiva-
tion. Although these field experiments provide compelling
empirical evidence to support this hypothesis, they shed little
light on the mediating mechanisms underlying choice overload.
What, then, are the processes that produce the decreases in sub-
sequent motivation exhibited in contexts that offer extensive
choices?
One possibility is that people encountering overly extensive
choices use a choice-making heuristic that necessarily leads them
to feel less committed to exercising their preferences. Previous
research has argued that limited-choice contexts invite people to
engage in rational optimization--to try to decide which option in
a set is the single best one for them. By contrast, choosers in
extensive-choice contexts may endeavor to balance the tradeoffs
between accuracy and effort, adopting simplifying heuristic strat-
egies that are much more selective in their use of available infor-
mation (Christensen-Szalanski, 1978, 1980; Payne et al., 1988,
1993). Consequently, extensive-choice contexts may invite people
merely to "satisfice"--to stop when they find any choice that
seems acceptable (Mills, Meltzer, & Clark, 1977; Simon, 1955,
1956). In other words, when people have "too many" options to
consider, they simply strive to end the choice-making ordeal by
finding a choice that is merely satisfactory, rather than optimal.
Doing otherwise would demand more effort than seems justified
by the prospective increase in utility or satisfaction. Hence, one
2 No actual grade proved lower than a "5," and grades were not restricted
to whole numbers.