The first 5 pages, shown as text so search engines and readers can find this document.
Page 1
PHYSICAL REVIEW RESEARCH 8, L022056 (2026)
Letter
Parastatistics and a secret communication challenge
Zhiyuan Wang *
Max-Planck-Institut für Quantenoptik, Hans-Kopfermann-Straße 1, 85748 Garching, Germany
(Received 6 February 2025; revised 9 May 2025; accepted 18 March 2026; published 23 June 2026)
One of the most unconventional features of topological phases of matter is the emergence of quasiparticles
with exotic statistics, such as non-Abelian anyons in two-dimensional systems. Recently, a different type of
exotic particle statistics that is consistently defined in any dimension, called R parastatistics [Z. Wang et al.,
Nature (London) 637, 314 (2025)], is also shown to be possible in a special family of topological phases.
However, the physical significance of emergent parastatistics still remains elusive. Here, we demonstrate a
distinctive physical consequence of parastatistics by proposing a challenge game that can only be won in
a noise-robust way using physical systems hosting paraparticles, as passing the challenge requires the two
participating players to secretly communicate in an indirect way by exploiting the nontrivial exchange statistics
of the quasiparticles. The winning strategy using emergent paraparticles is robust against noise, as well as the
most relevant class of eavesdropping via local measurements. This provides both an operational definition and
an experimental identity test for paraparticles, alongside a potential application in secret communication.
DOI: 10.1103/35db-l74g
Introduction. Topological phases [1–7] are long-range-
entangled phases of matter, exhibiting fundamentally new
physical properties compared to conventional symmetry-
breaking phases, and have attracted tremendous interest in the
condensed matter community. A key unconventional feature
of such phases is the emergence of exotic quasiparticle statis-
tics beyond the celebrated Bose-Einstein and Fermi-Dirac
statistics, which reflects the pattern of long-range entangle-
ment [8–10] in the topologically ordered ground states. For
example, non-Abelian anyonic statistics is possible in two
dimensions (2D) [1,2,11,12], where spatially braiding anyons
leads to a unitary evolution in the topologically degenerate
states with n identical anyons, realizing a representation of the
braid group Bn, and has a potential application in topological
quantum computation [1,12].
In higher spatial dimensions, it has long been believed that
all pointlike particles are either fermions or bosons [13–15].
There is actually a straightforward generalization of non-
Abelian statistics to arbitrary spatial dimension, known as
parastatistics [16], in which identical particles transform in
higher-dimensional representations of the symmetric group Sn
(instead of the braid group Bn) under exchange of their spatial
positions [17]. Although parastatistics has been considered
since the dawn of quantum mechanics [18] and extensively
studied by the high-energy physics community in the second
*Contact author: zhiyuan.wang.physics@gmail.com
Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further
distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s)
and the published article’s title, journal citation, and DOI. Open
access publication funded by Max Planck Society.
half of the last century [17,19–22], it is now widely be-
lieved to be physically equivalent to ordinary particle statistics
[13,20,22]. In other words, the theory of parastatistics, while
mathematically consistent, was long thought to predict no new
physical phenomena beyond what is already known from the
theory of fermions and bosons.
Recently, a paper [23] proposed a different theory of paras-
tatistics, now called R parastatistics, which exhibit exchange
behaviors dramatically different from our conventional phys-
ical picture of fermions and bosons. These R paraparticles
have been shown to emerge in a family of exactly solvable
quantum spin models [23] realizing an exotic class of topolog-
ical phases. Despite this significant progress, many important
questions are open, such as what are the most distinctive
physical (experimental) consequences of R paraparticles and
how to characterize their universal topological properties in-
dependently of the microscopic realization.
In this Letter, we demonstrate a distinctive physical con-
sequence of R parastatistics from a quantum information
viewpoint. Roughly speaking, we show that emergent R paras-
tatistics enable long-range communication of information by
only exchanging the spatial positions of paraparticles, with-
out either perturbing the environment or leaving any trace
of information behind. We formulate this idea by proposing
a secret communication challenge game, designed in a way
that can only be won by topological phases hosting emergent
paraparticles [24], as winning the challenge requires the two
participating players to send a message to each other in a
noise-robust way by exploiting the nontrivial exchange statis-
tics of the quasiparticles. We illustrate the winning strategy
using exactly solvable quantum spin models with emergent R
paraparticles (in both two and three dimensions) and show that
this strategy is robust against local noise and eavesdropping.
We give a simple description of the universal topological
properties of R paraparticles that involves only basic quantum
2643-1564/2026/8(2)/L022056(7) L022056-1 Published by the American Physical Society
Page 2
ZHIYUAN WANG PHYSICAL REVIEW RESEARCH 8, L022056 (2026)
FIG. 1. Illustration of the game process. Here, we draw the 2D
version for simplicity; in 3D, the circles become spheres. The two
circles have radius r0 defined by the players. During the game,
the Referees move the two circles along their respective paths to
complete an exchange of positions. The two far-separated points o, s
are chosen by the players, while the two paths are chosen by the
Referees.
mechanics and show that the winning strategy only relies on
these universal properties. We then systematically investigate
which three-dimensional (3D) topological phases can win the
game, using the established fact that pointlike topological
quasiparticles in 3D are universally described by symmetric
fusion categories (SFCs) [13–15]. This leads to a categorical
description of R paraparticles and the winning strategy, and
singles out a special class of 3D topological phases that can
win the game.
Rules of the game. The participants of the game consist of
two parties: two players, whom we call Alice (A) and Bob
(B), and a group of Referees (R). To win the game, the two
players are required to send a message to each other using a
very restricted class of local operations on a common quan-
tum many-body system, and the Referees’ role is to initiate
the challenge and monitor the whole process of the game to
prevent cheating.
Before the game starts, the players are allowed to discuss a
winning strategy, and then they are required to
(1) submit a locally interacting Hamiltonian ˆH on a 2D
or 3D lattice that has a unique, gapped, and frustration-free
ground state |G〉;
(2) choose the radius r0 of the circles (or spheres in 3D)
in Fig. 1, and two far-separated [25] points o, s in the lattice
(which are allowed to be on the boundary);
(3) experimentally prepare the ground state |G〉 for a suf-
ficiently large system size L r0 [L is determined by the
Referees after they receive (1) and (2)].
A few technical remarks are in order here. Gapped means
that there is a uniform lower bound (independent of the system
size L) on the energy difference between the first excited state
and ground state of ˆH. Frustration-free means that ˆH can be
written in the form ˆH = ∑
i ˆhi such that ˆhi 0 and ˆhi |G〉 =
0, which is a technical requirement imposed to simplify dis-
cussion, and we relax this requirement in the Supplemental
Material [26]. A few other technical regularity conditions are
also stated in the Supplemental Material [26].
When the Referees receive all above (1)–(3), they experi-
mentally check that |G〉 is prepared correctly, by verifying that
ˆhi |G〉 = 0 for all i. Then, Alice and Bob are led to separate
rooms and the Referees randomly pick two numbers a, b ∈
{1, 2, 3, 4}, and give them to Alice and Bob, respectively, who
do not know each other’s number. The goal for the players
is to gain information about each other’s number through a
restricted set of local operations on the physical system they
have prepared, as we describe below.
Once the game starts, any form of direct communication
between the players is prohibited. Throughout the game, Alice
and Bob are confined in separate rooms, where the only access
to the outside world is through local unitary operations and
measurements on the system they prepared, restricted to their
respective circle areas, as shown in Fig. 1(a). When the game
starts at t = 0, the state of the physical system is initialized to
be |(0)〉 = |G〉, and Alice’s circle starts at the special point
o, while Bob’s circle starts at the other special point s, as
shown in Fig. 1(b). Then, the Referees select the two paths
[27] shown in Fig. 1 and slowly move the two circles along
their respective paths simultaneously, ensuring that the two
circles remain far apart at all times. Throughout the process,
the Referees frequently check the local ground-state condition
ˆhi |(t )〉 = 0 everywhere beyond the two circle areas to make
sure that the players are not cheating by leaving any trace
of information behind. If at any moment the Referees detect
an excitation beyond the circle areas, the challenge fails. The
game ends at t = T in the configuration shown in Fig. 1(d),
when the two circles complete an exchange of positions. After
this, the Referees move both circles out of the system and
perform one last check of the local ground-state condition
ˆhi |(T )〉 = 0 everywhere. If this final check is passed, the
Referees ask Alice about b, and ask Bob about a, and the
players win if they both answer correctly.
What can the players do to win the game? They can cre-
ate some excitations inside their respective circle areas and
make measurements on them, but throughout the experiment
they are obliged to move the excitations to follow the cir-
cle movement, and clean up whatever excitations inside the
circles before the game ends at t = T , to make sure that
the Referees cannot detect an excitation anywhere beyond
the circle areas at any time. At first glance, the challenge
appears insurmountable under such restrictive conditions, as
the players need to communicate some information without
either leaving a trace behind or sending any physical particles
to each other as information carriers. Nevertheless, we will see
that it is possible to succeed if the ground state |G〉 hosts some
emergent quasiparticles with nontrivial exchange statistics.
The players can create such quasiparticles at t = 0 and encode
their numbers in the internal state of the quasiparticles. Then,
they move the quasiparticles following the circle movement,
and right before the game ends at t = T , the quasiparticles
have exchanged their positions, inducing a unitary rotation
on their internal states, which the players can measure. We
will see that some information can be sent this way if the
exchange statistics is nontrivial. In the following, we illustrate
L022056-2
Page 3
PARASTATISTICS AND A SECRET COMMUNICATION … PHYSICAL REVIEW RESEARCH 8, L022056 (2026)
this winning strategy in detail, using emergent paraparticles in
the some exactly solvable models.
Solvable quantum spin models with emergent R paraparti-
cles. The models can be defined in both 2D and 3D, as we
present explicitly in the Supplemental Material [26]. Both
models have unique, gapped, and frustration-free ground state
|G〉 and therefore satisfy the game requirement. The micro-
scopic details of these models are not important, as it turns out
that the winning strategy depends only on certain universal
topological properties of the emergent paraparticles that are
common to both models, which we summarize below:
(1) The state space. In general, an excited state of ˆH with
n identical paraparticles is denoted as |G; ia1
1 ia2
2 · · · ian
n 〉. Here,
i1, i2, . . . , in are the positions of the paraparticles, and we
assume that they are mutually different [28]. The numbers
a1, a2, . . . , an ∈ {1, 2, . . . , m} label the internal states of the
paraparticles, where m 2 is an integer called the quantum
dimension of the paraparticle. When the positions i1, . . . , in
are fixed, there are mn linearly independent internal states,
spanning an mn-dimensional subspace, which we denote as
Hi1i2···in .
(2) Topological degeneracy. The internal states of the para-
particles cannot be accessed using any local measurements
when all particles are far away from the boundary and from
each other. Formally, this means that any local operator ˆO is
diagonal in the subspace Hi1i2···in ,
〈G; ib1
1 · · · ibn
n
∣
∣ ˆO∣
∣G; ia1
1 · · · ian
n
〉 = CO
i1···in
n∏
j=1
δa j b j , (1)
where CO
i1···in is a constant. Equation (1) implies that states in
Hi1i2···in are topologically degenerate in energy [29].
(3) Particle movements. There exists a local unitary op-
erator ˆUik jk that moves the particle at position ik to a nearby
position jk, for any k = 1, 2, . . . , n:
ˆUik jk
∣
∣G; ia1
1 · · · iak
k · · · ian
n
〉 = ∣
∣G; ia1
1 · · · jak
k · · · ian
n
〉 . (2)
(4) Exchange statistics. Here, we focus on the case n = 2,
which is enough for our purpose; the generalization to arbi-
trary number of paraparticles is straightforward [26]. For i =
j, Hi j must be equal to H ji, since both describe the subspace
of excited states of two identical paraparticles at positions
i and j. Therefore, the two different bases {|G; ia jb〉 |1
a, b m} and {|G; jbia〉 |1 a, b m} must be related by a
unitary transformation:
|G; ia jb〉 = ∑
a′,b′
Rb′a′
ab |G; jb′
ia′
〉 , (3)
where the four-index tensor Rb′a′
ab (called the R-matrix) must
satisfy the Yang-Baxter equation [Eq. (S8) in the Supple-
mental Material [26]] so that Eq. (3) can be consistently
generalized to any number of particles [23]. Each R-matrix
defines a type of parastatistics [23]. There are many different
types of parastatistics that can emerge in condensed matter
systems, and for the two solvable models we present in the
Supplemental Material [26], the relevant paraparticles have
quantum dimension m = 4, and the nonzero elements of the
FIG. 2. Illustration of the winning strategy using emergent para-
particles. o and s are chosen to be the two special points where a
paraparticle can be locally created and measured, as described in
properties (5) and (6). The dashed lines represent the paths traversed
by the circles, along which the players have applied unitary operators
ˆUi j in Eq. (2).
R-matrices are given by
Rb′a′
ab = ±1, if (b′, a′) =
⎛
⎜
⎜
⎝
43 12 24 31
21 34 42 13
14 41 33 22
32 23 11 44
⎞
⎟
⎟
⎠
ab
, (4)
where (4, 3) is abbreviated as 43 and similarly for others, and
−1 (+1) is for the 2D (3D) model.
(5) Creation and annihilation of paraparticles. Paraparti-
cles can be locally created at the two special points o, s shown
in Fig. 2. More precisely, there exist unitary operators ˆUo,a,
ˆU ′
s,a localized around o, s, respectively, satisfying
ˆUo,a
∣
∣G; ia1
1 · · · ian
n
〉 = ∣
∣G; oaia1
1 · · · ian
n
〉 ,
ˆU ′
s,a
∣
∣G; ia1
1 · · · ian
n
〉 = ∣
∣G; ia1
1 · · · ian
n sa〉 . (5)
Since unitary processes are reversible, one can also annihilate
paraparticles at o, s using ˆU †
o,a, ˆU ′†
s,a, respectively.
(6) Measurement of the internal state. When a paraparticle
is close to either o or s, one can measure its internal state
locally: There exist observables ˆOo, ˆO′
s localized around o, s,
respectively, satisfying
ˆOo
∣
∣G; ia1
1 · · · ian
n
〉 = a1
∣
∣G; ia1
1 · · · ian
n
〉 , if i1 = o,
ˆO′
s
∣
∣G; ia1
1 · · · ian
n
〉 = an
∣
∣G; ia1
1 · · · ian
n
〉 , if in = s. (6)
Note that if we instead have ik = o for some k > 1 (or ik = s
for some k < n), then we need to use a basis transformation
in Eq. (3) [or more generally, Eq. (S14) in the Supplemental
Material [26]] to swap ik all the way to the front (back) before
applying Eq. (6) to compute 〈 ˆOo〉 (or 〈 ˆO′
s〉). We will see an
example soon in Eq. (7).
All these properties can be derived from the exact solution
of these two models, as we show in the Supplemental Material
[26]. We emphasize that in order to win the challenge, it is
crucial to have two special points o and s in the lattice where
a single paraparticle can be created and measured using local
operations, and these are the two points the players choose
at which they begin and end their journey. In the 2D model,
o and s are chosen to be at the intersection between two
different types of gapped boundaries, while in the 3D model,
they are chosen to be the positions of some special pointlike
topological defects in the bulk.
L022056-3
Page 4
ZHIYUAN WANG PHYSICAL REVIEW RESEARCH 8, L022056 (2026)
Winning strategy with emergent paraparticles. We now
detail the strategy that ensures success in the challenge. The
pregame preparation is done using either of the two solv-
able models mentioned above: The players submit the model
Hamiltonian ˆH, choose o, s to be the two special points in
Eqs. (5) and (6), prepare its ground state |G〉, and let the Ref-
erees verify. After the game starts and the players obtain their
numbers from the Referees, they use the following strategy to
win, as illustrated in Fig. 2:
(a) At t = 0, Alice applies ˆUo,a to create a paraparticle with
internal state a at o, and similarly Bob applies ˆU ′
s,b at s. The
state of the whole system is |(0)〉 = |G; oasb〉.
(b) Throughout the game process, Alice and Bob move
their paraparticles along the paths using ˆUi j in Eq. (2), closely
following the circle movement.
(c) When the exchange is complete, the state evolves to
|(T )〉 = |G; saob〉 = ∑
a′,b′
Rb′a′
ab |G; ob′
sa′
〉 , (7)
where we use Eq. (3). Then, Alice and Bob measure ˆO′
s and
ˆOo in Eq. (6) and obtain a′ and b′, respectively, after which
the state collapses into |G; ob′
sa′
〉. Finally, Alice and Bob an-
nihilate their paraparticles using ˆU ′†
s,a′ and ˆU †
o,b′, respectively,
so that the Referees cannot detect any excitations anywhere
after they leave the game.
According to the R-matrix in Eq. (4), the measurement
results a′, b′ are definite, and importantly, knowing b and
b′ completely determines a, and similarly, knowing a and
a′ completely determines b [30]. For example, if Alice has
(a, a′) = (2, 3), then she searches in the second row of the
matrix for the column that has a′ = 3. This turns out to be the
fourth column, so she determines that b = 4 and b′ = 1. This
allows the players to win the game with a 100% success rate.
This winning strategy highlights a clear physical distinc-
tion between paraparticles and ordinary fermions or bosons
with an internal symmetry, such as color or flavor. The statis-
tics of the latter can also be described by Eq. (3), but with
Rb′a′
ab = ±δa′aδb′b. Therefore, if ordinary fermions or bosons
are used in this strategy instead of paraparticles, Alice will
simply obtain a′ = a and Bob will obtain b′ = b, which con-
tains no information about each other’s number, and therefore
cannot win the game with a probability better than pure guess-
ing. A more careful argument that ordinary fermions and
bosons cannot win the game in a noise-robust manner using
any possible strategy is given in the Supplemental Material
[26], and a formal proof is given in Ref. [31].
It is important to emphasize again that this strategy
relies only on the topological properties (1)–(6) of emer-
gent paraparticles, which are universal characteristics of the
underlying topological phase independent of the detailed
microscopic realization. In particular, any quantum system
hosting quasiparticles satisfying properties (1)–(6) with a non-
trivial R-matrix (i.e., Rb′a′
ab is not of the trivial product form
Rb′a′
ab = pa′aqb′b) can pass the challenge. Therefore, we can use
properties (1)–(6) as a definition of R paraparticles [31,32].
Finally, while winning the challenge in 3D unambiguously
demonstrates nontrivial R parastatistics [27], in 2D it is pos-
sible that some special types of non-Abelian anyons can also
win. In the Supplemental Material [26], we design a twisted
version of the game that can prevent a class of non-Abelian
anyons from winning, and more general antianyon twists are
given in Ref. [31].
Robustness against noise and eavesdropping. Importantly,
the above winning strategy using emergent paraparticles is
robust against noise, which is a consequence of Eq. (1). More
precisely, the susceptibility to local noise decays exponen-
tially as e−l/ξ , where l is the minimal distance between the
paraparticles and the boundary. This means that even when
noise is present, the above strategy still has a high chance of
success that is independent of the system size L. Equation (1)
also implies the robustness against the most physically rel-
evant class of eavesdropping via local measurements: When
both players are in the bulk, an eavesdropper cannot obtain
any information about the players’ numbers a and b using any
local measurements on the system, even including measure-
ments at o, s or inside the circle areas.
Symmetric fusion category description. So far, we have
presented solvable models in 2D and 3D with emergent
paraparticles that can pass the challenge. We now give an
alternative description of the winning strategy using the
framework of SFC, which gives a universal description of
pointlike quasiparticles in 3D topological phases [13–15,33–
35]. We will see that certain 3D topological phases described
by a special class of SFCs can win the game; an example is the
3D solvable model given in the Supplemental Material [26].
The SFC description of the winning strategy is based on
the following space-time diagram:
(8)
where σ represents a special type of topological quasiparticle,
with ¯σ being its antiparticle. In this case, the players need to
prepare a state with topological quasiparticles σ and ¯σ at po-
sitions o and s, respectively, which can still be the unique and
gapped ground state of a locally interacting (but not transla-
tionally invariant) Hamiltonian that qualifies the requirement
of the game, as shown in the Supplemental Material [26].
Importantly, we assume that the quasiparticles have fusion
rules of the form [36]
σ × ψ = m σ, ψ × ¯σ = m ¯σ , (9)
where m is the quantum dimension of ψ. Equation (9) implies
that ψ can be locally created and measured in the vicinity of
σ or ¯σ , and the tensor Rb′a′
ab in Eq. (8) defines the statistics
of the paraparticle ψ in the sense of Eq. (3). Indeed, Eq. (8)
exactly describes the winning strategy similar to that depicted
in Fig. 2, in which at t = 0 Alice creates a paraparticle with
internal state a in the vicinity of σ , and meanwhile Bob creates
a paraparticle with internal state b in the vicinity of ¯σ ; at t = T
when the exchange process is over, Alice measures the inter-
nal state of her paraparticle in the vicinity of ¯σ and obtains
a′, and then fuses her paraparticle into ¯σ , and meanwhile Bob
performs similar operations in the vicinity of σ and obtains b′.
As long as R is nontrivial, some information can be transferred
between Alice and Bob, and by using multiple identical layers
L022056-4
Page 5
PARASTATISTICS AND A SECRET COMMUNICATION … PHYSICAL REVIEW RESEARCH 8, L022056 (2026)
of the same system, the players can transfer more information
to each other, thereby arbitrarily enhancing the chance of
winning. We therefore conclude that a gapped ground state
|G〉 described by an SFC C can win the challenge if C has
fusion rules of the form (9) such that the R-matrix defined
by Eq. (8) is nontrivial [37]. The 3D solvable model given in
the Supplemental Material [26] is described by an SFC of this
type. A more detailed categorical analysis is presented in a
separate paper [31].
Discussion. We have presented a secret communication
challenge that demonstrates a distinctive physical feature of
paraparticles. In a nutshell, emergent parastatistics in topolog-
ical phases enables long-range communication between the
two players solely through an exchange of their positions,
without either perturbing the environment or leaving any trace
of information behind. Such a winning strategy using paras-
tatistics is robust against any local noise and eavesdropping,
which cannot be achieved using ordinary fermions or bosons.
We can therefore use this challenge game as a criterion and an
operational definition for nontrivial parastatistics.
We emphasize that our secret communication challenge
games fundamentally differ from prior nonlocal games in
topological phases [38,39] in goal and design. These prior
nonlocal games are played on the 2D toric code; their main
goal is to demonstrate noise-robust quantum advantage, while
our goal is to demonstrate the nontrivial physical consequence
of R parastatistics, an intrinsically quantum many-body phe-
nomenon that only occurs in certain exotic topological phases.
Finally, we discuss some potential future directions. One
interesting direction is to experimentally implement this chal-
lenge game and its winning strategy using systems that host
emergent paraparticles. The first critical step would be en-
gineering such a system and preparing its ground state. The
latter can potentially be achieved by generalizing the recent
topological quantum state preparation protocol [40,41] in-
volving measurements and feedforward to quantum double
ground states based on an exotic class of solvable groups
[42]. Another interesting direction is to generalize the chal-
lenge game and its winning strategy to quantum many-body
systems at finite temperature (and more generally to mixed
states). In 2D, there is no topological order at finite temper-
ature [43–46]. In 3D, however, some nontrivial features of
topological order persist at finite temperature [47,48]. Suc-
cessfully achieving this challenge at finite temperatures is
crucial for experimentally observing emergent parastatistics.
Additionally, this could highlight a nontrivial feature of finite-
temperature topological order and its potential application in
quantum information.
Acknowledgments. We thank Alexei Kitaev, Xiao-Gang
Wen, J. Ignacio Cirac, Meng Cheng, Kaden Hazzard, Norbert
Schuch, Chong Wang, Dominic Else, Sung-Sik Lee, Tao Shi,
and Xiaoqi Sun for discussions. This work was supported by
the Munich Quantum Valley (MQV), which is supported by
the Bavarian state government with funds from the Hightech
Agenda Bayern Plus, and the Munich Center for Quantum
Science and Technology (MCQST), funded by the Deutsche
Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) under Germany’s Excellence
Strategy (EXC2111-390814868).
Data availability. The data that support the findings of this
article are openly available [51].
[1] A. Y . Kitaev, Fault-tolerant quantum computation by anyons,
Ann. Phys. 303, 2 (2003).
[2] A. Kitaev, Anyons in an exactly solved model and beyond, Ann.
Phys. 321, 2 (2006).
[3] X.-G. Wen, Topological orders in rigid states, Int. J. Mod. Phys.
B 04, 239 (1990).
[4] M. A. Levin and X.-G. Wen, String-net condensation: A physi-
cal mechanism for topological phases, Phys. Rev. B 71, 045110
(2005).
[5] X. Chen, Z.-C. Gu, and X.-G. Wen, Local unitary trans-
formation, long-range quantum entanglement, wave function
renormalization, and topological order, Phys. Rev. B 82, 155138
(2010).
[6] X. G. Wen, Colloquium: Zoo of quantum-topological phases of
matter, Rev. Mod. Phys. 89, 041004 (2017),.
[7] M. Barkeshli, P. Bonderson, M. Cheng, and Z. Wang, Symmetry
fractionalization, defects, and gauging of topological phases,
Phys. Rev. B 100, 115147 (2019).
[8] M. Levin and X.-G. Wen, Detecting topological order in
a ground state wave function, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 110405
(2006).
[9] Alexei Kitaev and John Preskill, Topological entanglement en-
tropy, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 110404 (2006).
[10] Y. Zhang, T. Grover, A. Turner, M. Oshikawa, and A.
Vishwanath, Quasiparticle statistics and braiding from
ground-state entanglement, Phys. Rev. B 85, 235151
(2012).
[11] G. Moore and N. Read, Nonabelions in the fractional quantum
Hall effect, Nucl. Phys. B 360, 362 (1991).
[12] C. Nayak, S. H. Simon, A. Stern, M. Freedman, and S. Das
Sarma, Non-Abelian anyons and topological quantum compu-
tation, Rev. Mod. Phys. 80, 1083 (2008).
[13] S. Doplicher, R. Haag, and J. E. Roberts, Local observables and
particle statistics I, Commun. Math. Phys. 23, 199 (1971); Local
observables and particle statistics II, 35, 49 (1974).
[14] T. Lan, L. Kong, and X.-G. Wen, Classification of (3+1)D
bosonic topological orders: The case when pointlike excitations
are all bosons, Phys. Rev. X 8, 021074 (2018).
[15] T. Lan and X.-G. Wen, Classification of 3+1D bosonic topo-
logical orders (II): The case when some pointlike excitations
are fermions, Phys. Rev. X 9, 021005 (2019).
[16] H. S. Green, A generalized method of field quantization, Phys.
Rev. 90, 270 (1953).
[17] Robert H. Stolt and J. R. Taylor, Correspondence between
the first- and second-quantized theories of paraparticles, Nucl.
Phys. B 19, 1 (1970).
L022056-5